Skip to main content

Human-Centered Healthcare Design—Designing for Healing

By Sara Graham

How can human-centered design impact healthcare settings? Human-centered design in architecture is the focus on the users of the space, instead of a generalized solution that may or may not address the needs of those users. One approach to initiating human-centered design is by allowing the users and patients to be a part of the design process from the beginning. Using their needs, desires for the space, and expertise in their area of work allows for the newly designed space to be more effective when the user inhabits it. This collaborative effort allows the group to truly determine what is needed and how to best design the space so that it aids in performance and healing. 

Designing ways to create place attachment is a technique that should be considered. Allowing the users and patients to have personal artifacts or embellishments, as well as letting them assist in the selection of furnishings and finishes, creates a sense of ownership and attachment. Giving the user a sense of ownership eases the healing process while creating a more comforting atmosphere for each individual. Finding ways to allow the built space to support the patient aids in healing, lowers stress levels, and creates a sense of possession.  

Human-centered design through place attachment is of course, much easier to cater to for staff and more long-term patients, but finding a way to make even short-term patients or residents feel at home can contribute to their healing experience. Creating an area that connects the personal and community space where place attachment can take place blends the areas more smoothly. One way this can be achieved is to create an alcove or “porch” for each resident suite where they can place furniture and décor as they like. This allows the transition of personal and communal space to feel more fluid and gives residents more space to call their own. 

TSA has incorporated this design technique on a regular basis. Meadow Peak at Summit Vista is one recent example where human-centered design was applied. In the patient rooms, built-in shelving was designed so that each resident could display personal artifacts, plants and/or photographs of loved ones to create a more personal, homelike space. In addition to their individual rooms, an area was provided within the community’s shared space to which residents are able to contribute. In the main corridor, TSA’s team and Meadow Peak’s owner and staff created a display unit where each resident can display the artwork they create. Allowing each resident a place to display a little part of themselves within the shared space gives a special location for place attachment, even outside of their personal resident rooms. It is small details like this that allow for large impacts on patients healing through human-centered design.

Tips to Avoiding Complications During Construction

By Marnie Jacobsen

At TSA Architects, we strive to continually improve our drawings to help contractors and owners understand the intent of the design and avoid problems during construction.

Healthcare buildings are constantly changing as medical procedures improve. The majority of the projects we work on with our healthcare partners are renovations of existing facilities. TSA enjoys helping healthcare providers to increase efficiency and reduce the clutter in their office spaces, i.e. operating, procedure, exam, and patient rooms.

About a year ago, we asked an estimator from a large construction company in Salt Lake City to give us a contractor’s perspective of construction drawing sets. We wanted to know what we could do to improve our drawings to make them more useful for contractors to use during bidding and building.

Here are their top 2 tips for renovation projects. 

Tip #1 — Include floor plans for the levels above and below the area to be remodeled. 

There are few projects that do not require new lighting, telecom lines, plumbing fixtures, ductwork or heating and cooling equipment. Each item requires a connection to services located in other areas of the building. For example, showing the floor directly below the remodel will help the plumbers know what healthcare areas could be disrupted while a new waste line is installed. A new hole will need to be drilled in the floor, which is often constructed of concrete and metal decking. Chipping concrete and drilling through metal is loud, causes vibration, and makes a mess above and below the drill site.  Once the floor is cut, the plumbing waste line requires a downward slope to allow gravity to move the contents in the correct direction. The length and path of the line can vary depending on the location of the closest existing vertical waste pipe. In each case, plumbers need to access the ceiling on the level below and then navigate through the interstitial space, all while cutting pipe, climbing up and down ladders, and connecting each length together.    

Including the floor plan below or above a remodel project can help the contractor to plan for disruptions, avoid costly delays during construction, and anticipate the use of specialized equipment that will be necessary to protect patients from infection while they are being treated or healing after a procedure.

Tip #2 — Identify the roofing type in the construction drawings.

No matter what building level the renovation is located on, there will almost always be something —such as a plumbing vent line or new heating and cooling equipment, that will need to be run up to and through the roof. Maintaining the watertight nature of the roof system is essential to the success of the remodel. During site investigation, the architect and consultants should access and walk the roof area to verify the condition and material type. Including the facility manager in the site walk and asking for background information on the roof, such as the age and brand of materials, any problem areas, previous roof installations below the existing system, etc. would also be advantageous.

Providing roof information on the construction drawings will help the contractor to understand existing conditions and avoid cost and timeline complications during construction.

One more thing to keep in mind — providing the current warranty company on the drawings will earn the architect bonus points with the contractor.  And we love that!

Do you really want a shorter schedule?

By Sean Bujold

Get it done.  I need it yesterday.  Decision, decisions, decisions! 

We live in a world where everything is now.  Yesterday would be even better.  However, design and construction projects take a substantial amount of time. Almost every client wants to have a shorter schedule. As an architect, I am tasked with creating a schedule for design that meets the owner’s needs while also coordinating with the engineers, equipment suppliers, city and state reviewers, and a host of others. 

The most significant challenge for writing a schedule is providing enough time for decisions to be made.  The design team must develop the best solution: layout the rooms, define the exterior wall construction, meet the budget, provide appropriate mechanical and electrical systems, etcetera.  All these choices get filtered through the owner’s review and acceptance. Individual departments and users need to understand and agree upon the presentation.  Is this the correct solution for their needs? 

When writing a design schedule, I focus on what decisions need to be made and when.  Designing and building are challenging because of the myriad of decisions that need to be made.  Choices made now live on in the building for many years to come.  I sometimes describe my job as predicting the future. The design team and owner’s choices impact how the space is utilized throughout the life of that project.  More often than not the most significant time needed is for the users and the owner to become comfortable with the selections that have been made. Rushing through the design will leave tracks in the sand that cannot be wiped away without another construction project. 

First time owners building anything struggle with the schedule.  A client came to me years ago saying the bank was putting restrictions on when she had to have the construction started.  I told her we could meet the schedule, but the strain would be on her to understand, accept and be comfortable with the choices that had to be made in a very timely manner.  Happily, we made her schedule, the bank was satisfied, and she’s been working in the facility for many years.  My hat goes off to her for accepting the challenge of a very quick schedule.

Designing takes time.  Institutions that build regularly gain a better understanding of the decision-making process and the time needed for their projects to be successful.  Despite our desire for speedy solutions, the key element is to always allow enough time for the best decisions to be made. 

Healthcare Design – It’s Personal

By Tracy Stocking

In September of 2009, I was diagnosed with bone cancer. Over the next 8 months, I spent approximately 40 days and nights in a state-of-the-art patient room in a state-of-the-art flagship hospital. I was in good hands, cared for by dedicated and compassionate doctors, nurses, social workers, and others.   

As a healthcare architect, I tried to be attuned to my environment and learn from this experience. The patient rooms were properly planned with caregiver access near the door and visitor space on the perimeter wall. Large windows provided ample comforting views and natural light. The nurse-call, lighting controls, bed control and TV remote control were all convenient and easy to use. 

However! There was one key element of the environment that was sadly sub-standard: Noise.  

Sleep and rest – key elements to recovery and healing – were surprisingly and disappointingly hard to achieve. As I lay awake and unable to sleep, I tried to identify the various sounds that were keeping me awake. Some were easy, like 2 nurses talking loudly outside my door, or the frequent code announcements over the intercom. Some were more challenging, like dragging heavy furniture or equipment across a floor somewhere above me – in the middle of the night! 

If you are lucky enough to have not spent a night in a hospital patient room, just imagine your worst hotel night ever. It’s like that. 

So far, I have not been able to find an elegant design solution. I’ve explored sealing the door with sound gaskets and automatic door bottoms. The gaskets help, but facilities folks won’t accept the door bottoms because they are notoriously difficult to maintain.  

Sound masking has been suggested. This is a sound system that produces white noise and can be somewhat effective in helping with acoustic privacy in Exam rooms, but not good enough for patient rooms. 

Finish materials such as floors, walls and ceilings all have a role to play in acoustic performance. Hard smooth surfaces, which are typical and required inpatient care areas for the purpose of infection control, exacerbate unwanted noise. While it may be tempting to replace sheet-vinyl floors with carpet (deep-pile shag anyone?) or level-5 painted gypsum-board walls with heavily texture wallcovering, these are obviously not allowed by hospital construction codes and guidelines.  

I’ve considered adding a vestibule or anteroom to every patient room – like in an Airborne Infection Isolation room.  In light of the recent pandemic, this would add the benefit and flexibility of providing more “Covid Isolation” rooms. This may be one of the best ideas out there, but it comes with a significant increase in construction costs that most hospitals aren’t willing to accept.  

So what is the solution? People and technology!  

First – the care team (meaning every hospital employee) should be aware of and sensitive to patient comfort. Administrators, physicians, nurses, every permutation of caregiver,  housekeepers, maintenance, dietary, etc, must keep this top of mind. Here are a few simple measures that every hospital could adopt:  

  • Wear soft-soled shoes in patient units.
  • Don’t talk in patient unit corridors.
  • Schedule cleaning and maintenance work between 8 and 5 – when most patients are awake.
  • Control general paging in patient units and rooms.

Second – the patient could benefit from a nice pair of noise-canceling headphones or earbuds. This might sound simplistic and not “design-ey” enough but consider the benefits: 

  • the patient has control – they could provide their own
  • they hospital could provide them
  • they could be plugged into the nurse-call & intercom system

When faced with a similar challenge the late famous architect Michael Graves arrived at a similar elegant non-architectural solution. He had designed a dramatic skylight in the master bedroom of a mansion for a wealthy sheik. The client later complained that the light of the moon prevented him from sleeping at night. Michael, as creative as he was, could not come up with a design solution that didn’t compromise the elegance of the design concept. On the flight across the ocean to present the sheik with a brilliant solution, he was given a sleep mask by a stewardess. That was his light-bulb moment. Upon meeting the sheik, he presented a sleep mask as his non-architectural yet simply elegant solution. 

Virtual Reality and Architecture: Visioning in Another Dimension

In recent years, a revolutionary new visioning tool that has the ability to rapidly convey architectural concepts to clients has joined the scene and architecture as we know it will never be the same. VR, or virtual reality, takes concepts from a flat picture and converts them into an actual experience, allowing the design team and clients to gain more tangible sense of how the new project will function. The feedback received via VR experience is more informed and therefore more valuable.

Below, Haley Meyer, architect-in-training shares some of the ways VR takes the architectural process to the next level:

  1. VR is invaluable as it takes the next step in user interaction. It allows for the user to be fully immersed in a sensory experience as if it were real and to be able to grasp more complex design ideas that can’t be understood on paper or by simply looking at a screen.
  2. VR relates to architecture in the sense that allows the user to grasp concepts at a cheaper price point rather than when it’s too late and already built. It also allows for the user to experience scale and helps them to visualize how they would fit into and feel within a space. It takes the process of architecture from just drafting to a real visualization experience that can engage them and can become a team building experience in bringing the entire team together towards the common goal. The design team can then see exactly where the user might have questions and be able to coach them through the design choices.
  3. VR would be a valuable service for our clients as it helps to blur the line between the predictable and the unknown and helps to correct project outcomes by seeing these flaws in a simulated setting. In turn, the client will be able to save money in the long run by being able to catch things that otherwise might not be understood in drawings. The user can go beyond just looking at drawings, and take themselves into a “rendering” that allows them to look around at their future space they are investing in. It allows the user to be able to make changes on the fly while envisioning what their building will look like when it all comes together. It also allows for users to utilize their own smart phone technology so that they can take this information to their cohorts to get a more well-rounded design and make changes based on what they see “walking” through the space. This could prevent future change orders if this is not what the owner intended.
  4. In order for a project to come to fruition from a concept to a building, the client and design team’s relationship is key. The project team meets with the client in the very beginning to discuss needs and lays out the types of rooms and equipment that will be needed in the space. Adjacencies and relationships can be better understood at this stage, and whether it be a new or old building, the best and most efficient space can be realized. This will also help to better understand what scheme works best for day to day use and circulation for the end users. After a successful layout is agreed upon, the team drafts up a plan of what form this might take, and then upon having more input and refinement, the 3d model is completed. The model is designed in a modeling software where it is generated in the computer. After this, the model can be viewed in virtual reality so that the user can “walk” around the space and make adjustments, such as moving equipment around. This will allow the design team to get an immediate response to what does and doesn’t work, and the process can be streamlined to get the best result possible. This can be presented as a video that goes through all the spaces in the interior and exterior, or it can be conveyed through virtual “goggles” so that client can see the building live and pan around and theoretically be in the space.

In the end, virtual reality allows for the client to wrap their head around the design at an earlier stage rather than a costly fix down the road of the project.